Alt-History Fault Line #3 — Fomenko vs. Illig (Time Revision Math Mutually Exclusive)
Open questionTwo rival theories that recorded chronology is wrong — Fomenko's shifting of antiquity into the Middle Ages and Illig's claim that 297 years (614-911 CE) never happened — mathematically contradict each other, and both fail independent checks against retro-calculated astronomy (eclipses, planetary positions). Both remain quarantined; the finding is that even within the time-revision genre, the claims falsify one another.
The engine's record — word for word
Fomenko shifts thousands of years of antiquity into the Middle Ages. Illig claims 297 years are missing (Phantom Time Hypothesis 614-911 CE). The two revisionist math structures are NATIVELY INCOMPATIBLE — a Fomenko-correct chronology falsifies an Illig-correct chronology and vice versa. Both are independently falsified by retro-calculated astronomy (eclipses, comets, planetary positions) which Russian Academy of Sciences Chronology Commission (1998-2004) verified. Engine: Apr 17 audit divergence already quarantines both; this V2 finding strengthens by documenting the internal incompatibility — even within the time-revision register, alt-history claims falsify each other.
Walk this on the live map →